My Depression Is Not Your DepressionOn the Best Brain Possible Facebook page, I’ve learned from experience to be very choosy about any posts on depression because people can get really passionate and colorfully expressive about their mental health.  Many have strong opinions about whether the condition is based on biology, thinking, or lifestyle. Whenever I post an article about antidepressants, I find out real quickly that people either love them or hate them.

Recently, I posted the piece, Depression Doing The Thinking from Psychology Today (credible source, right?), explaining that:

One of the features of depression is pessimistic thinking. The negative thinking is actually the depression speaking. It’s what depression sounds like. Depression in fact manifests in negative thinking before it creates negative affect.

My Depression Is Better (or worse) Than Your Depression (nah, nah, nah, nah, nah)

A conversation with a follower ensued:

Follower: Depression is an illness not a behavior. This approach isn’t much different than telling a depressed person to just snap out of it. Please don’t contribute to perpetuating myths about mental illness.

Me: Depression is a multi-faceted condition attributed to many things including thinking habits. Is all depression just thinking? No. Is all depression biological? No. Please allow for both.

Follower: If that was directed at me, I don’t need a lecture, thank you. I have suffered from depression for decades. There’s a chance I know what I’m talking about. I appreciate, however, that it is very difficult for someone who doesn’t suffer from a mental illness to understand what it’s like. That’s a large part of the challenge of breaking the stigma.

MeI suffered from depression for decades and tried to commit suicide twice. So, does that make you or me an expert on depression? NO! It makes you the expert on YOUR depression and me the expert on mine. Every case is unique and different. I can’t begin to know what is best or the solution for anyone else. All I can do is take care of myself, tell what worked FOR ME, and share information. That’s what I’m doing.

When writing my reply, I thought, “Really?  Are we really going to get into a competition about whose depression is more legit?”

No one’s depression is more real than anyone else’s because no one’s depression is the same as anyone else’s. It’s like comparing apples to oranges — and grapes. You just can’t do it.

Depression Defined

Depression is an umbrella term for many different mental health conditions, behaviors, and symptoms. In Deeper Than Down In The Dumps, I write:

Depression is a complex illness with a basis in brain neurochemicals and thought patterns with many other contributing factors such as life events, environment, biochemicals, and heredity. 

Just as there’s not a single definition or manifestation of depression, there’s no one medical test to confirm a diagnosis. A diagnosis is a professional opinion based on clusters of symptoms exhibited and various test results. Lab tests are generally run to rule out other physical problems which may be causing the depressive symptoms, such as thyroid disease.

In The Down Side Of Antidepressants, I explain:

The truth is that, just as there is a great deal still unknown about how the brain functions, experts aren’t really sure how antidepressants work. You might have seen depression explained as a “chemical imbalance” or a “serotonin deficiency.” It’s not quite that simple. We really don’t know what causes depression, how it affects the brain, or what’s a cause and what’s a symptom even.

I think we can all agree that depression isn’t just a matter of will, but I don’t think we can begin to decide what depression “should” look like, whose is worse, or what’s the best treatment for someone else.

While medications alone can and do help some people, others find success in altering their behavior through mindfulness, affirmations, positive thinking, prayer, meditation, cognitive behavioral therapy, physical exercise, or by adding supplements or changing their diet.

After decades of taking antidepressants, I tried to commit suicide resulting in a serious brain injury. While healing the brain injury, I healed my depression — because maybe I got my brain functioning optimally for the first time in my life or maybe it was because of all the other life changes I made. When I quit looking for an easy fix in a pill or therapist and confronted and worked through my issues and altered my behaviors and thinking, the depression lifted and my life and mental health grew infinitely better as I got stronger, more resilient, and positive.

Will the strategies that worked for me work for everyone? No. Each person has to find the right solution for them. Will making healthier food choices, exercising, and learning mental health tools hurt anyone? No. Should options without the side effects and risks of medication be tried before taking antidepressants? Most definitely yes — except in urgent situations.

I have an acquaintance who does yoga about every day, exercises, meditates, is a healthy eater, and doesn’t find relief from her depression with these practices. Does that make her depression more real than mine? No. It makes it different and more challenging to resolve.

Kinds Of Depression

For the record, there are generally nine recognized subsets of depression:

  • Major – extreme sadness, hopelessness, lack of energy, irritability, trouble concentrating, changes in sleep or eating habits, feelings of guilt, physical pain, and thoughts of death or suicide lasting for more than two weeks and usually recurring.
  • Dysthymia – low mood over a long period of time. People can function adequately, but not optimally. Symptoms include sadness, trouble concentrating, fatigue, and changes in sleep habits, and appetite.
  • Postpartum is characterized by feelings of extreme sadness, fatigue, loneliness, hopelessness, suicidal thoughts, fears about hurting the baby, and feelings of disconnect from the child after a woman gives birth.
  • Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD) – usually starts in early winter and lifts in the spring, is likely due to a decrease in sunlight, and can be treated with light therapy. Symptoms include anxiety, increased irritability, daytime fatigue, and weight gain.
  • Atypical – commonly includes a sense of heaviness in the arms and legs, like a form of paralysis, in addition to oversleeping and overeating. People with the condition may also gain weight, be irritable, and have relationship problems.
  • Psychotic – is a mental state characterized by delusions and hallucinations. About 20 percent of people with depression have episodes so severe that they see or hear things that are not there.
  • Bipolar Disorder – is also called manic depressive disorder and has four subsets of its own. It consists of periods of extreme lows followed by periods of extreme highs.
  • Premenstrual Dysphoric Disorder (PMDD) –  is a type of depression that affects women during the second half of their menstrual cycles and is more severe than PMS. Symptoms include depression, anxiety, and mood swings.
  • Situational – is triggered by a stressful or life-changing event, such as job loss, the death of a loved one, trauma — even a bad breakup. Situational depression tends to clear up over time on its own but can turn into major depression.

image source: https://www.flickr.com/photos/reem_faran/

5 Comments

  1. Sandra Pawula Reply

    This is so helpful to know, Debbie. I know several people suffering with depression. You’ve helped me understand that there’s not one solution and I need to support them each as the beautiful individuals they are.

    • I am so glad, Sandra. We all need to check ourselves here and stop the judgement of each other. I find that I even tend to automatically make opinions around this issue and have to consciously remind myself of the blog’s sentiments. Just as with anything in life, we all are different and have to find our own ways.

  2. Pingback: 6 Depression Treatments You Might Not Know About - The best brain possible

  3. Sherisse M. Reply

    Yet another great thoughtful and intelligent post, Debbie. 🙂
    People just like to be argumentative and conflictive, because they like to be “right” (whether they suffer from depression or not). Honestly, I think those that constantly view their depression as some uncontrollable illness often relegate themselves to the status of ‘victimhood’ and pivot their entire lives around a state of hopelessness and inaction. I know that in itself is a negative judgment but that’s just what I’ve gathered from reading countless self-analyzing articles of depression around the net. Happens a lot in ‘pop culture’ sites and the likes. Depression sucks, but we are not victims nor does depression ‘identify’ us. It’s a part of who we are but we are NOT our illness! ….Wish more people had your wisdom and shared your views. 🙂

    • Thank you for your kind words and support, Sherisse. I agree with everything you expressed. Well said.

Write A Comment

Get information and inspiration on how to have your best brain and life delivered right to your inbox.
We respect your privacy.